“At first you will be disorientated and confused, and, indeed, a little vexed. It is to be expected. But direct your anger elsewhere. I am a friend. Let me help you stand…” – Mordecai, Gladiator II

As well as taking half a billion dollars at the box office, winning five Oscars including Best Picture and Best Actor, and creating more memorable quotes than most movies have dialogue, Ridley Scott’s Gladiator is often credited as resurrecting the ancient historical epic – a setting largely absent from cinema screens since the 1960s. However, there was a proposed sequel for the film that would also involve resurrection…

Following Gladiator’s success, star Russell Crowe asked his fellow Australasian, singer-songwriter Nick Cave, to pen a sequel. When Cave brought up the little inconvenience of Crowe’s character, Maximus Decimus Meridius, dying at the end of the film, Crowe replied:

“Yeah, you sort that out.”

And he did.

Cave had only written one film at this point, Ghosts …of the Civil Dead, for director John Hillcoat, but he approached the Gladiator II script with gusto, creating a narrative that indulges in issues of faith, the fantastical, and the violent. He stated in an interview with NME that “It was a stone cold masterpiece. I enjoyed writing it very much because I knew on every level that it was never going to get made.” The script has since surfaced online and offers a fascinating glimpse at what could have been:

The plot begins the day after Gladiator ends – but in purgatory; a rain-soaked, muddy eternity where desperate souls hope of being ferried to Elysium. Here Maximus finds the decrepit gods lingering in a ruined temple who charge him with killing their brother Hephaestus. Wandering through a nightmarish desert Maximus learns that his murdered son, Marius, was resurrected and adopted by a Christian family, and upon finding the emaciated, dying Hephaestus, he too is brought back to life – 18 years after his death in the arena.

Maximus finds the now adult Lucius, nephew of the slain Emperor Commodus, leading the Roman genocide of Christians after his mother, Lucilla, was stoned to death after converting to Christianity following Maximus’ death. With the help of his old friend Juba, Maximus finds his son and offers help to the beleaguered Christians in Rome. Maximus transforms them into an army to stand against Lucius, and the two sides meet in a bloody battle in the woods outside the city.

Juba and Lucius are killed, but Maximus gives the order to rearm and prepare for further conflict. As he does so he encounters a dying stag, and approaching the animal the film becomes a vision of Maximus’ future as we see him leading Medieval Crusaders in the Holy Land, in the snows of a European battlefield, surrounded by tanks in WWII, fighting in the jungles of Vietnam and, finally, in a suit sat at a table in the Pentagon.

Fade to black.

… Are you not entertained?

In the words of its author, “Let’s call it a popcorn dropper.”

On first reading this sounds like a ridiculous sequel to a sublime original. The supernatural, fantastical elements clash with Gladiator’s stoic sincerity and portrayal of history (however inaccurate it may be) while the heavy focus on early Christianity – a feature notable by its absence in the first film – is often awkward and unsubtle. Some may even question Maximus’ morality, as he essentially converts a group of pacifists into a blood-soaked army.

However, the film is an interesting homage to its generic roots; while Gladiator was essentially a pastiche of Spartacus and The Fall of the Roman Empire, Gladiator II evokes elements of classics such as The Robe, Quo Vadis and Ben-Hur. Furthermore, the idea of bringing the dead back to life was a feature in classical literature; in Lucan’s Pharsalia, for example, the witch Erictho reanimates a dead soldier who can foretell the future, much as Maximus appears to do in the closing montage.

Scott has said of the script that “Russell didn’t want to let it go, obviously, because it worked very well. When I say ‘worked very well’, I don’t refer to success. I mean, as a piece it works very well. Storytelling, [it] works brilliantly.” Cave’s dialogue may lack the almost Shakespearian tone of Gladiator, but one must applaud his ambition. The script contains various nods to the first film, including sequences involving Maximus’ dreamlike homecoming through the fields of wheat, as well as returning characters and a spectacular set-piece involving a flooded Colosseum where a mock-naval battle is staged. There are also plenty of wonderful characters for actors to sink their teeth into, especially Mordecai, a phantasmagorical companion to Maximus who can traverse between this life and the next.

Gladiator II had the potential to be absolutely terrible, but in Scott’s hands and with a redraft or two from the writers of the original it could have been epic. Scott is renowned for visual sensibility and seeing him tackle the evocative descriptions of a purgatorial wasteland and a sea battle in the Colosseum is a seductive proposition. That said, the former arguably found form in John Hillcoat’s The Proposition, which was penned by Cave. Scott likewise tackled the crusades with Kingdom of Heaven and Crowe…well, next time you see his veteran crusader in Robin Hood or his Pentagon operative in Body of Lies, both directed by Scott, just think…is that actually Maximus, echoing in eternity?

line

Is it thumbs up or thumbs down for Gladiator II? Or are you just terribly vexed? Pray to the gods or leave us a comment below with your thoughts.

About The Author

I’m studying for my PhD in Film Studies at Exeter University, building on my BA in Ancient History by researching the Ancient Historical Epic in film. I also help run the university’s cinema and write, present, edit and produce a film show, Cameo, for the student TV station XTV. I hope to move into making films and TV after graduation, especially as a writer and/or researcher, but will continue my love of film journalism as far as I can. ‘A Beginner’s Guide To…’ is my pet project for ORWAV, as well as history-related articles, reviews and other features.

  • trashfilmguru (Ryan C.)

    Interesting stuff! I thought “Gladiator” was a mess, and to be honest, I think Ridley Scott is probably the most over-hyped filmmaker of all time — I like “Blade Runner” and “”Alien” and that’s it — but a “Gladiator” sequel written by Nick Cave? That I’d have paid to see, regardless of who directed it!

    • James

      Agreed, Gladiator was pretty bad. But I’d pay to go to the theatre and watch eternal war through the ages in purgatory, written by Cave.

    • chrisdavies24

      Haha! Each to their own! Cave’s script certainly has some inventive stuff in there; I was sceptical at first as Gladiator is my favourite film, but after reading the script I though it could make for a really different, adventurous sequel. I’m currently writing my PhD thesis on ancient historical films and think Gladiator is a masterpiece, but Cave’s incorporation of Christianity and the conflict between Roman gods and the new faith was really interesting and different. Maybe it’ll get made one day…

      (ps, thanks for your Likes and support trashfilmguru – I’m really grateful for it. Hope you enjoy future articles too!)

      • trashfilmguru (Ryan C.)

        Of course my friend, I always enjoy reading your stuff!

      • http://gravatar.com/moraghannah marrog

        Oh, oh, have you seen Agora? (Sorry, I just never like to miss the chance to gush about that movie wherever possible.) I swear it’s topical for like a billion reasons!

    • https://www.facebook.com/g33kmommy Melissa Liming

      It has to be a joke that you thought Gladiator was bad. That was an amazing movie, and one of the only few recently that I agree’d with being the movie of the year at the Oscar’s. You must have one heck of a standard if you thought that movie was bad. Ugh.

      • trashfilmguru (Ryan C.)

        No, my standards aren’t particularly high — or low — just kind of weird. I know a lot of people liked “Gladiator” — fine, more power to ‘em, glad they enjoyed it. I just got kind of a “meh, I can take it or leave it” vibe from it. I felt like it was a scattershot, sort of directionless affair on the whole, buoyed by a lot of CGI to mask a pretty standard plot. But I fully realize I’m in the minority with that opinion.

  • https://www.facebook.com/hola.backgrinder Hola Backgrinder

    Cave’s Gladiator II story idea sounds like it owes a bit of a debt to Ben Bova’s Orion series.

  • Aafsdfa

    Tim Burton is the most over hyped of all time in my opinion.

    • Dave

      Quentin Tarantino

      • http://twitter.com/RK_usaf RJAK (@RK_usaf)

        No, he hypes his movies but as you see in his filmography… they’re worth it as he has every right to do so. Selling out for Dodge commercials he won’t do but you get the idea.

  • Pingback: Nick Cave on Gladiator 2: “It was a stone cold masterpiece. I enjoyed writing it very much because I knew on every level that it was never going to get made.” | Cakado / Buzz()

  • Mike Matinez

    Sounds like he was influenced by a long-forgotten series of adventure novels written by Barry Sadler decades ago. Casca: The Eternal Mercenary was a great adventure series that followed the Roman soldier who pierced Christ’s side and was cursed to an immortal existence of conflict. The series followed him through the ages as he fought alongside pirates, Vikings, all sorts of soldiers and was even a gladiator slave who won his freedom much like Crowe’s character in the film. Very interesting. The books would make a great series for cable, but would probably be expensive.

  • Pftally

    The Propostion was a great movie, Gladiator was pretty good, adding other symbolic/historic levels to it could be interesting

  • https://www.facebook.com/john.corri.byrne.district1 Corri Byrne

    I thought the first Gladiator stole key concepts from a 1964 film called Rise of the Roman Empire- check out the synopsis here- http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058085/plotsummary?ref_=tt_ov_pl

  • https://www.facebook.com/TheMadReagent Jason Variant

    so basically nick cave played “God of War” and copied the ending …. ok

    • Mike

      Gladiator came out in 2000……. The first god of war released in 2005.

    • Qwe qwe

      Hahaha yeah dude the playstation game god of war is completely original and is the first example of multiple era lifetimes in stories ever

  • http://bearokopoulos.wordpress.com bearokopoulos

    I’d feel a bit better about the Roman gods vs. Christianity aspect, except that Hephaestus is Greek, not Roman. Vulcan is the Roman equivalent.

    Pedantic, but still…

  • Brock T.I. Penner

    Russell Crowe is from New Zealand. Just thought I’d point that out.

    • https://www.facebook.com/cory.casella Cory August Casella

      He said fellow Australasian, not fellow Australian.

  • http://ginaslittlesecret.wordpress.com GLS Admin

    Reblogged this on Travel, Reviews & What's New and commented:
    we sometimes live in our dreams, hide in the darkness and think of what might have been….Mike GLS

  • Pingback: Dog-sledding in the District, one man’s hobby is Reddit’s spectacle()

  • https://plus.google.com/+AdamWykes Adam Wykes

    Sounds like Cave’s script is starting from the proposition that Maximus is the western concept of Liberty personified, and his script asks its audience to consider the full implications of Liberty’s worldview.

    And on a completely unrelated note, did anyone else notice how much like Paul Atreides this makes Maximus?

  • http://twitter.com/jgreenedzp James Greene (@jgreenedzp)

    With the utter crap coming out of Hollywood these days, why the hell not?

  • Russell Cox

    I’d rather see the next installment of Master and Commander

  • http://www.deborahmcadams.com Deborah McAdams

    Love it.

  • http://gravatar.com/feverdr Michael Fever

    Gladiator was an amazing movie of its time. I loved it. If you didn’t like it then there’s likely something wrong with you. Gladiator II….. do it man! I feel bad for Ridley who is likely still mourning the death of his brother (due to anti-depressants!!)… Make this movie.

  • Pingback: HEP – 71 – …And then Laurence Fishburne Rides His Octoshark into the Colosseum | Human Echoes Podcast()

  • Qwe qwe

    I’d be completely on board with this. Read the screenplay and it couldn’t possibly be worse than the first one. Dialogue at least would be tolerable